Future-Proofing SEO: How to Stay Ahead Amid AI Disruption & Search Diversification

Been looking forward to this one… Oliver Kuttruff addresses an impossible topic: future-proofing SEO! 

Is SEO really dying?

Image source

With AI-generated answers and social media platforms like TikTok eating into search behaviour, it certainly feels that way. And honestly? A lot of the hype is true. Google is changing, traffic patterns are shifting and some brands are already feeling the pinch.

But SEO has never been static. It has evolved through every major disruption, and this time is no different. The real question is: How do we build strategies that last, even when we have no idea what's coming next? Let's break it down!

Contents:

• Accepting that SEO will never be the same again
• Future-proofing SEO: what actually works?
• Tips for long-term success

Accept that SEO will never be the same again

AI is eating top-of-funnel (ToFu) traffic 

Google’s AI overviews are keeping users on search results pages, answering questions before they even need to click. Some brands say they're losing so much traffic that they're taking legal action—like Chegg, which is suing Google, claiming that AI-driven search results have gutted its revenue (NY Post, 2025).

But there's a silver lining.

AI chatbot referrals may actually convert better.

A study of 7 million sessions by Kevin Indig found that visitors from AI-generated search results stayed on site longer (10.4 vs. 8.1 minutes) and viewed more pages (12.4 vs. 11.8 pages on average). Why? Because by the time they click through, they've already done their research on GenAI tools, so they're closer to converting.

And there's another upside: AI could actually lead to more searches. Because these tools make it easier for users to refine and expand queries, we could see an overall increase in search volume. More complex searches mean more nuanced, high-intent opportunities—if you're ready to seize them.

Search is diversifying beyond Google

People aren't searching the way they used to and some aren't searching at all.

TikTok, Reddit, and other social platforms are replacing traditional searches. Instead of typing "best running shoes" into Google, people are scrolling through their feeds, getting recommendations from creators they trust, and making decisions without ever seeing a search results page.

The numbers back it up: 

• 74% of Gen Z use TikTok for search, and 51% even prefer it to Google (HerCampus via eMarketer, 2025). They don't want SEO-optimized fluff. They want real people with real opinions.
• Especially if you're in e-commerce, social media and marketplaces are huge. In 2023, 49% of U.S. shoppers say they start product searches on Amazon, 18% on social and other marketplaces, and only 34% on Google (CivicScience, 2023)

If your strategy still relies too heavily on Google traffic, you're on shaky ground. Your audience is shifting. The question is, will you follow it?

Future-proofing SEO: What actually works?

I hate catchphrases BUT we have to accept that search is changing at an unprecedented rate! What is true today may not be true in a few months. How do we prepare for the unknown?

Strategy & execution: A hypothesis-driven approach

Taking a hypothesis-driven approach to SEO is the best way to prepare! We don't know what's coming. It's all hypothetical until we test it. Some tactics will work, some won't, so you have to stay flexible and adjust on the fly.

Here's the rough process:

1. Define short- and long-term goals.
2. Establish strategies & tactics to move you toward those goals.
3. Track leading indicators to catch problems early. If short-term wins don't materialize, your long-term strategy is already at risk; pivot before it's too late.

You can't afford to sit and wait a whole quarter just to realize that something isn't working. Short-term wins and long-term bets should be mutually reinforcing.

Example:

"We want to increase the number of organically sourced customers by targeting high-intent buyers in Industry X."

• Tactic: Create bottom-of-funnel (BOFU) content around key use cases.
• Tracking success:
• Long term: # new customers
• Short-term:
• Are you ranking for BOFU keywords your ICP is looking for?
• Are visitors converting on these pages (newsletter signups, demo requests, etc.)?

If these short-term signals aren't moving, it's a clear early warning that your long-term goal isn't being met. That's your cue to adjust your tactics before the whole strategy collapses.

How do you use this approach to adapt to the unknown?

• Monthly reviews → Adjust short-term tactics based on performance.
• Quarterly reviews → Reevaluate the overall strategic approach.

This keeps your strategy fluid and responsive to external changes. The key? Never lose your hypothesis-driven mindset. Always test new angles, experiment with fresh ideas.

Important: We need to get more flexible with how we measure success. If traffic drops because users are researching via AI overviews or ChatGPT, that doesn’t automatically mean your SEO is failing. It just means we need to track different things.

For example:

• Mentions & prominence in Gen AI answers for key prompts (e.g. “What is the best XYZ?”)
• Impressions over clicks: Visibility still matters, even if users don’t always visit your site
• Revenue & sales: If traffic dips but revenue holds or grows, you’re still winning

Don’t panic over declining traffic if your brand is still being seen, trusted, and converting where it counts.

Tips for long-term success

So much for the meta stuff. But you came here for some real tactics and insights—I got you! Here are my bets for the future. Maybe they will spark some inspiration.

1. Build for Authenticity, Trust & Expertise

It sounds similar to EEAT, but I'm not talking about some Google ranking factor. It's what real people actually want in a web overflowing with AI-generated content.

In B2B, 75% of decision makers, including C-suite executives, say thought leadership content has led them to explore products or services they hadn't previously considered (Edelman, 2024). That's the power of trust and expertise.

People crave human connection—real voices, strong opinions, and content that actually adds value. If your strategy is still about checking off keyword boxes instead of engaging your audience, you're doing it wrong.

Great content gets shared, sparks conversations, and brings people back.

So what does that mean? Build your thought leaders in-house, get them on LinkedIn and on your website, get expert guests on your blog, use different formats like video ... stand out from the crowd with big brain power.

2. Distribution is Key: Don’t Just Wait for SEO

Yes I know, you came here for SEO tips. But fuck silos. You're leaving money on the table if your content lives only in search results.

Great content isn't just for Google, it should also drive social, paid, and sales efforts:

• Social teams repurpose blog posts for LinkedIn and TikTok.
• Google Ads teams use landing pages in campaigns.
• Sales teams get customized content to answer recurring customer questions.

In the best case, every piece of content has a distribution plan baked into its briefing, so it is used, shared, and generates value long before it ranks. Big plus: Even if rankings drop and AI kills Google all together, the content will still be worth its money.

Example: We built hyper-specific industry pages for a client. Before they even ranked, we plugged them into a targeted Google Ads campaign. The result: Conversions from day one.

3. Deepen Customer Research: Go Beyond Attribution Models

Where do your customers really come from? Attribution models are flawed. They give you a superficial view, but miss the big picture. Instead of relying on last-click data, go straight to the source:

• Ask them directly. Use self-reported attribution: "Where did you first hear about us?"
• Dig deeper. What content did they consume? What ultimately convinced them to buy?
• Identify patterns. Where do they spend time online? Which channels are actually influencing their decisions?

Example: Last week, I spent an hour with a client's sales team and walked away with months worth of content ideas. Real customer pain points, recurring objections, and insights you'd never get from Google Analytics alone.

4. Optimize for AI Search (If It’s Sending You Traffic)

AI chatbots aren't just a trend. They're already driving quality traffic, influencing purchase decisions, and giving first-mover advantage to brands that create citable, authoritative content.

Here’s what I’m doing:

• Tracking AI referral traffic

For some clients, AI is already a legitimate traffic source—but it behaves differently to other channels. Users coming from AI platforms have done their homework before they click. They've asked their questions, compared options, and are now closer to making a decision. More upfront research = higher conversion potential.

• Monitoring brand visibility in AI-generated results
  Even if AI isn't driving massive traffic yet, it's shaping brand perception. Who's being mentioned? Who isn't? And why? If your competitors are showing up more often, it's time to figure out what they're doing right.

• Reverse-engineer AI citations
  AI doesn't pull answers from thin air, it pulls from specific sites. So find out what's being cited, understand why, and make sure your brand is in the mix.

This space is evolving fast. Keep testing!

5. Technical SEO Still Matters (More Than Ever)

No matter how much SEO evolves, technical fundamentals will always be relevant.

Here’s what still matters:

• Crawlability, indexability, and internal linking. If search engines and AI chatbots can’t access your content, you don’t exist.
• Minimizing JavaScript reliance. Many AI bots can’t properly render JS (SEO Südwest, 2025). If your key pages are hidden behind complex scripts, you’re cutting yourself off from AI-driven search and referral traffic. 

Editor’s Note: Haven’t got to grips with JavaScript SEO yet? Take our free on-demand JavaScript SEO course.

• Make your site accessible. SEO isn’t just about rankings, it’s about ensuring your content reaches everyone. Many users rely on assistive technologies, and excluding them means lost traffic, lost engagement, and lost business (next to the OBVIOUS ethical reasons).

TL;DR Summary

SEO isn't dead. But if you're still playing by the old rules, your traffic just might be.

The key to future-proofing? Stay flexible, focus on value, and stop relying solely on Google.

Here's what winning strategies look like today:

• Authenticity and engagement INSTEAD OF keyword stuffing. 
• Content distribution INSTEAD OF just waiting for rankings.
• Customer research INSTEAD OF outdated attribution models.
• AI & social optimization INSTEAD OF resisting change. 

The choice is simple: Adapt or fade away.

You might also like:

• Why Small Businesses Need to Think Beyond Google & Build Brand
• Brand Building vs Performance Marketing vs SEO
• Webinar: In the Age of AI, is Structured Data Dead?