Beyond identifying implementation issues, ensure canonicalisation makes sense and aligns with business needs. Canonicalisation doesn't control indexing but can influence it; incorrect canonicals can cause valuable pages to be ignored or replaced in results.
Flag any missing canonicals.
Flag any incorrect canonicals (pages canonicalising to inaccurate URLs).
Setting an explicit page-level canonical is best practice. Not setting one means that URL is the canonical by default, which can be fine for small, simple sites. If the site uses parameters (especially tracking), explicit canonicals are recommended so variations are handled correctly.
This is a sense check; the corresponding Sitebulb Hints (on the right) are the reports to review for unexpected errors.
Correct implementation isn't enough if the canonical strategy itself is wrong. A canonical pointing to the wrong page can hand rankings to a weaker URL or suppress a page you want to rank.
Templates canonicalise variations to the wrong master page.
Parameterised pages have no canonical strategy at all.
Auditing Canonicalized Pages by Sitebulb
Guide to Canonical Tags by Stevy Liakopoulou
Sitebulb
Find, fix and communicate technical issues with easy visuals, in-depth insights, & prioritized recommendations across 300+ SEO issues.
Get all the capability of Sitebulb Desktop, accessible via your web browser. Crawl at scale without project, crawl credit, or machine limits.