In GSC's Page Indexing report, review the indexed and not-indexed URL details to identify error responses Google knows about but which may not surface during a standard site crawl. A crawl only finds URLs it can reach via links; GSC surfaces URLs Google has encountered by any means, including sitemaps, external links, and historical crawl data.
Document 4xx and 5xx errors found and review for prioritisation.
Replicate in Bing Webmaster Tools or other consoles as relevant.
Note whether errors are legacy URLs with no current internal links, or URLs that should still be valid but are erroring.
Gather user, business, and SEO value data on broken URLs to support prioritisation.
Some broken URLs never appear in a crawl because nothing links to them anymore, yet Google still tries to reach them. Surfacing these from GSC catches errors a link-based crawl alone would miss.
Old URLs were deleted but are still indexed or linked externally.
A migration left orphaned error URLs that only Google remembers.
Find & Fix GSC Errors by Tory Gray
Manual check (GSC)
Find, fix and communicate technical issues with easy visuals, in-depth insights, & prioritized recommendations across 300+ SEO issues.
Get all the capability of Sitebulb Desktop, accessible via your web browser. Crawl at scale without project, crawl credit, or machine limits.