Confirm that non-existent URLs return a proper 404 (Not Found) or 410 (Gone) status code, not a soft 404 (an empty or error page served with a 200 status). Error pages should show a helpful message explaining the error, with directions and links to help users find their way. 410 signals permanent removal, 404 signals not found; both are valid.
Confirm this two ways:
Visually: does the URL serve a user-friendly error page (not a blank or broken one)?
Technically: does the URL return the correct 404 or 410 status (a 200 is an issue)?
Check the status issues on the erroring URL itself; it shouldn't redirect to a /404 page or similar.
Review Error Page Setup (written instructions).
Find Soft 404s (written instructions).
Manually view an example error page to see if there's a user-friendly message.
Review corresponding Sitebulb Hints.
Error handling matters for both users and crawlers. A soft 404 (error content served with a 200) tells search engines the page is fine when it isn't, wasting crawl budget and cluttering the index.
A CMS returns a styled error page with a 200 status instead of a 404.
Missing URLs redirect to the homepage or a /404 page rather than erroring in place.
Mastering 4XX Errors: A Comprehensive Guide Using Sitebulb by Chidinma Itsuokor
Error 404 Guide for SEO & Usability by Tory Gray
How To Properly Serve Up 404s on Single Page Application (SPA) Pages for SEO by Gray Dot Co
Sitebulb, Manual Check (Site)
Find, fix and communicate technical issues with easy visuals, in-depth insights, & prioritized recommendations across 300+ SEO issues.
Get all the capability of Sitebulb Desktop, accessible via your web browser. Crawl at scale without project, crawl credit, or machine limits.